Bethany has competed in the Hoosier Academic Superbowl since its inception in 1987. Bethany competes in class IV (based on school size) and has qualified at least one team for the state competition every year but one. To advance to the state competition, a team must place in the top five scores from around the state at an area competition.
| Year | Team | Rank |
| 1987 | Fine Arts | 1st |
| Science | 1st | |
| Math | 1st | |
| Social Studies | 3rd | |
| 1988 | Math | 1st |
| 1989 | English | 2nd |
| English | 4th | |
| 1990 | All-Around | 4th |
| 1991 | Fine Arts | 4th |
| 1992 | Fine Arts | 1st |
| Interdisciplinary | 1st | |
| 1993 | Math | 3rd |
| English | 5th | |
| 1994 | Math | 4th |
| Social Studies | 4th | |
| 1995 | Fine Arts | 2nd |
| Social Studies | 5th | |
| 1996 | ||
| 1997 | Fine Arts | 1st |
| English | 2nd | |
| 1998 | Interdisciplinary | 1st |
| Science | Finalist | |
| 1999 | Fine Arts | 1st |
| 2000 | Fine Arts | 1st |
| Social Studies | 1st | |
| 2001 | Social Studies | 1st |
| Fine Arts | Finalist | |
| Math | Finalist | |
| 2002 | Fine Arts | 1st |
| Science | 1st | |
| Language Arts | 2nd | |
| Social Studies | 2nd | |
| Interdisciplinary | 2nd | |
| 2003 | Interdisciplinary | 1st |
| Science | 2nd | |
| 2004 | English | 3rd |
| Math | 4th | |
| 2005 | Social Studies | 3rd |
| Math | 3rd | |
| English | 4th | |
| 2006 | Social Studies | 2nd |
| 2007 | Mathematics | 5th |
| 2008 | Fine Arts | Finalist |
| 2009 | Math | 3rd |
| Fine Arts | 4th | |
| Interdisciplinary | 4th | |
| 2010 | Fine Arts | 5th |